WAF (ASX) WAF valuation

Originally posted by eshmun ↑

CMM just raised A$107 million in debt funding for Bibra through Macquarie and the management were never shy about telegraphing to the market that the money for the mine would be a combination of debt and equity. Judging by the size of the debt component relative to the total funding required as set out in the CMM's updated feasibility, the actual final debt to equity ratio is more weighted towards debt which will protect shareholder's long term profits (EPSs) in the future should the mine be built and successfully commissioned within budget.

The equity component of the Bibra funding has yet to be announced and the share price of CMM shares has been able to get some benefit from the rising gold price tailwinds. I'm not sure of the reason for the delay in raising the risdual equity in this company's case, ie whether they were hoping for the share price to get some traction before the raising or some other more pedestrian reason, but the net result of waiting is that the share price has risen and any raising will likely be at a higher price than just a few short weeks ago.

I've made the point before that given WAF were not building the mine using a turn-key contract model it should have given them (together with their pre-existing and sizable cash treasury) more flexibility in terms of when they decided to raise the equity component. WAF shareholders were informed post-raising that the equity raising was just the "reality" but we don't know if it represented a non-disclosed part of the funding agreement or a prerequisite condition of the debt funding. Shareholders should have a right to know if the equity raising and also the timing of the equity raising was forced on the company or not because if it was this represents an undisclosed and added cost of obtaining the debt which has clearly cost existing shareholders through the lost value of future earnings per share via the dilution. The price of the raising was also quite discounted considering the supposed quality of the project and there are accelerated rights issues that can be instigated which can be done almost as quickly as capital raisings to institutional investors but with the benefit of not diluting existing shareholders.

Now I understand your argument with respect to higher risks in BF so therefore a bigger squeeze on existing shareholders come the time for funding but part of the compensation for the funders is the general higher grade and better metrics of the projects that pass the sniff test in Africa. The bar is higher and that's also how risk gets mitigated. Take for example Sanbrado vs Bibra. Sanbrado is forecasting debt pay-back in less than 2 years, whereas Bibra are working on more than 5 years. The intitail grades at Sanbrado are more than 4 times higher than Bibra. That is also how the risk/reward and risk mitigation works for the funders between Africa and Australia. In the case of Sanbrado their money is paid back faster at presumably a higher (disclosed) cost. The funders are willing to take the risk on lower grade (more marginal) projects in Australia with slower pay-back times. This represents the natural risk arbitrage for the funders when deciding to fund projects in locations with vastly differing sovereign risk profiles. Considering we were told we were the batchelor giving out the roses to 14 short listed funders why did we get such a disappointing and opaque outcome?

I think I've got the right to use the term "sold down the river" because from where I sit the current pushing this canoe the wrong way still seems pretty strong. Esh

Expand

Excellent post Eshmun and you have earned the right to say whatever you want here given your track record over many years and your willingness to share your deep knowledge in the mining industry with us all.

It’s hard to argue with what you have said. I do sense there was considerable pressure on Mr Hyde to make the deal happen. Maybe they were worried about the sovereign risks or the Financial Markets which had already begun to correct. Maybe their patience ran out and they just decided to get this thing moving ASAP. Nevertheless, I think they were trying their very best to prove up the value of this deposit prior to financing.

Not sure exactly what went down and maybe we are being protected from the finer points but I imagine the Bachelor scenario may have turned into a date with the ugly sisters.

Looking forward, risk/reward has obviously been impacted but we’re no dead duck by any means.

No.	Vol.	Price($)
2	12485	$1.49

No.

Vol.

Price($)

12485

$1.49

Price($)	Vol.	No.
$1.50	132100	7

Price($)

Vol.

No.

$1.50

132100

No.	Vol.	Price($)
1	3670	1.360
1	4785	1.355
4	42574	1.350
2	26140	1.345
1	4986	1.340

No.

Vol.

Price($)

3670

1.360

4785

1.355

42574

1.350

26140

1.345

4986

1.340

Price($)	Vol.	No.
1.370	46444	4
1.375	84504	4
1.380	66843	2
1.385	20785	3
1.390	109785	4

Price($)

Vol.

No.

1.370

46444

1.375

84504

1.380

66843

1.385

20785

1.390

109785

(20min delay)
Last $1.50		Change 0.015(1.01%)		Mkt cap ! $1.866B

Open	High	Low	Value	Volume
$1.51	$1.51	$1.49	$3.699M	2.471M

Excellent post Eshmun and you have earned the right to say...

Scientific conference spotlights PYC's work on blindness disease treatment

Sales growth pushes Lovisa's fortunes (and shares) upwards

Panic, paranoia, and gangland politics: HotCopper users react to Dubber's missing $26M

Bigtincan's Board backs Investcorp offer: Why a NASDAQ listing could be game-changing

Pan Asia rebranding to 'clear confusion' after bagging $35M for Chile projects

MinRes's Ellison knows he screwed up – for that reason, hunt for new Chair to be sped up

HotCopper Highlights: Your most watched stocks for Week 47, 2024

To make modern missiles, you need 3D Printing. And in that gold rush, Amaero is selling shovels

Week 47 Wrap: HotCopper users' most watched; Brent lifts on Putin's scary letter; RFK dents CSL

Dale Gillham's weekly wrap: Sigma-Chemist Warehouse merger creates pharma powerhouse

Buyers (Bids)

Sellers (Offers)

Excellent post Eshmun and you have earned the right to say...

Top Stories

Scientific conference spotlights PYC's work on blindness disease treatment

Sales growth pushes Lovisa's fortunes (and shares) upwards

Panic, paranoia, and gangland politics: HotCopper users react to Dubber's missing $26M

Bigtincan's Board backs Investcorp offer: Why a NASDAQ listing could be game-changing

Pan Asia rebranding to 'clear confusion' after bagging $35M for Chile projects

MinRes's Ellison knows he screwed up – for that reason, hunt for new Chair to be sped up

HotCopper Highlights: Your most watched stocks for Week 47, 2024

To make modern missiles, you need 3D Printing. And in that gold rush, Amaero is selling shovels

Week 47 Wrap: HotCopper users' most watched; Brent lifts on Putin's scary letter; RFK dents CSL

Dale Gillham's weekly wrap: Sigma-Chemist Warehouse merger creates pharma powerhouse

Buyers (Bids)

Sellers (Offers)