the big soak up, page-16

OK so I guess it has become more about having an argument between me and you cuppa, so I have duly asked them to moderate my last comment, which, its true, took your line out of context, and was just cheap point-scoring. My bad.

Having said that, you've done the same thing to me, and have pursued this argument with just as much glee as I have.

Having a bit of a stoush about companies and shareprices is something I enjoy and learn from, but I'm really sick of your continual ad hominem attacks on me.

A "smokescreen"?? Please! You have got to be joking. You originally wouldn't believe I had sold HRL and bought EHR - now you use it to back up your argument. I don't see why you can't argue with me without attacking me.

As for feeling threatened by HRL - no quite the opposite - HRL offers the gleaming hope for what can happen when a stock comes to the attention of the market. I have had ample opportunity today and yesterday to take a position in HRL for more than 10% less than I sold it. The only reason I don't is because all of the publicity makes it hard to figure out what a good price is.

My original call (when it was trading at 7.7 - 8c) of Short Term sell on HRL, that pissed you off so much, has been proven to be at least half right. My call of buying EHR (at the time) was at least half wrong.

While I enjoy a good discussion/ debate/ argument, this has gotten ridiculous. Stop focussing on me, it won't make the share price go up.

I'm not threatened by HRL, how ridiculous, especially given the trading prices in the last couple of days. I could have bought for a good 10-14% less than I sold.

You started this by calling me I liar when you felt threatened by my post.

http://hotcopper.com.au/post_threadview.asp?fid=1&tid=1666991&msgno=7795445#7790894

Also its "you're" not your.