And then, your view on share buyback program, as conducted by RMD. Specifically, you have expressed reservations with RMD's practice of "automatic and continuous purchases".
But, considering the following:
- The company operates in a field (OSA and related sleep disorders) that is structurally growing.
- It is the industry leader, reinforcing its position via the biggest R&D budget compared to its competitors.
- It has a demonstrated track record of superior growth in Revenues, Profits, Cash Flows and Dividends.
- It has surplus capital on its balance sheet and adds to that surplus every year.
Now assume the following:
- The company's intrinsic value will continue to increase in the future, much like it has over an extended period in the past.
Surely, a continuous buyback program is an eminently sensible thing to do given the set of circumstances in which RMD finds itself, as described above (quite a luxurious and enviable set of circumstances, it warrants saying)?
If not, what would be the alternative mechanism by which to accelerate returns to shareholders?
Special dividends? As a shareholder, I would far prefer shares to be bought back and cancelled so that I, as a long-term shareholder end up being a holder of a larger slice of the same earnings pie. I like the idea of extinguishing equity interests that never need servicing
Of course, if the business in question was a cyclical business, and a buyback risked being made at the top of the price cycle, thereby destroying the value of shareholder capital, then a sustained and ongoing buyback could indeed be argued to be a dubious practice, but when the business is one that has both a history and ability to increase in intrinsic value over time, what is wrong with conducting a buyback at any time when there is excess capital?
Finally, your tendency to not sell shares puts us in a bit of a like-minded position.
But you say you don't tend to buy anything too often either? Presumably, that means you build up cash from time to time. How do you reconcile buying discipline with "timing the market" which, if your cash balance becomes material, and the longer it remains that way, is effectively what you are doing?
Expand