Hi Everyone,
I have now completed scraping tips spanning back to January 2018 and have processed for ranking too.
I have two issues currently in calculating and reporting rankings.
The first one is some inconsistency of results, caused by lack of full ASX+Chi-X data. The reason for that being my data is neither completely ASX nor ASX+ChiX. I have linked the tipping calculations to my Access database which collects both ASX and Chi-X through my daily scans since late last year. However, whenever my daily (automated) scans failed to complete the process, I occasionally run a historical data retrieval through an API to fill the gaps, but these data do not include Chi-X. And essentially any data before November 2018 are ASX only.
So, this has caused slight variations in the wins, and also percentage gains compared to Free's system. I hope to do a comprison in the next few days to see if the variances are acceptable or otherwise.
I am considering three options to mitigate / eliminate the above issues:
1. Mitigation - Go through the top ranked players and see if there are any significant issues with calculations. So far the tip processing has been done completely through automation, so I am hoping to do some manual intervention in the next few days.
2. Temporary solution - If someone send me full data (i.e. ASX and Chi-X, at least covering 12 months) I can use them along with my daily scan data for the near future.
3. Long term solution - Either I have to subscribe to full data or competition is run only on ASX data.
The issue number 2 is sort of conflict of interest with my own tips and ranking, most likely to be a short term one. Will explain that in a separate post with rankings.
Following are 117 tips that were submitted since 1 Aug 2018. I have used that cutoff because our previous system stopped somewhere there, and thought if someone wants to update their own spreadsheets without missing many, I would put all the tips since August here. Apologies for the long post, but will submit only active tips from the next week.
Good luck to all tipsters!Wazza3006, BOT, TA, Long, 18/01/19
https://hotcopper.com.au/threads/short-term-trading-week-starting-14-jan.4602607/?post_id=37150439
Wazza3006, AZY, TA, Long, 17/01/19
https://hotcopper.com.au/threads/short-term-trading-week-starting-14-jan.4602607/?post_id=37149565
8horse, ISD, FA, Long, 09/01/19
https://hotcopper.com.au/threads/short-term-trading-week-starting-7-jan.4596901/?post_id=37074183
Create, XPE, TA, Long, 03/11/18
https://hotcopper.com.au/threads/short-term-trading-weekend-lounge-2-4-nov.4521220/?post_id=36377537
Dazedandconfused, AIS, FA, Long, 26/10/18
https://hotcopper.com.au/threads/short-term-trading-week-starting-22-oct.4498780/?post_id=36275827
RockstarJones, A3D, FA, Long, 09/10/18
https://hotcopper.com.au/threads/short-term-trading-week-starting-8th-oct.4479207/?post_id=36044297
Ibza, ASN, TA, Long, 08/10/18
https://hotcopper.com.au/threads/short-term-trading-week-starting-8th-oct.4479207/?post_id=36038663
dunjo, AER, FA, Long, 07/10/18
https://hotcopper.com.au/threads/short-term-trading-weekend-lounge-5-7-oct.4478387/?post_id=36029973
dunjo, LPE, FA, Long, 07/10/18
https://hotcopper.com.au/threads/short-term-trading-weekend-lounge-5-7-oct.4478387/?post_id=36029939
dunjo, SP3, FA, Long, 07/10/18
https://hotcopper.com.au/threads/short-term-trading-weekend-lounge-5-7-oct.4478387/?post_id=36029969
dunjo, UBI, FA, Long, 07/10/18
https://hotcopper.com.au/threads/short-term-trading-weekend-lounge-5-7-oct.4478387/?post_id=36029961
8horse, ISD, FA, Long, 03/10/18
https://hotcopper.com.au/threads/short-term-trading-week-starting-1-oct.4468478/?post_id=35983215
952i, BIT, TA, Short, 03/10/18
https://hotcopper.com.au/threads/short-term-trading-week-starting-1-oct.4468478/?post_id=35983853
Michaeljob, YOW, FA, Long, 03/10/18
https://hotcopper.com.au/threads/short-term-trading-week-starting-1-oct.4468478/?post_id=35973297
PhoenixAM, AJM, FA, Long, 03/10/18
https://hotcopper.com.au/threads/short-term-trading-week-starting-1-oct.4468478/?post_id=35972041
Kaz008, SI6, TA, Long, 02/10/18
https://hotcopper.com.au/threads/short-term-trading-week-starting-1-oct.4468478/?post_id=35961386
riseabove, NVA, TA, Long, 28/09/18
https://hotcopper.com.au/threads/short-term-trading-week-starting-24-sept.4450085/?post_id=35906315
Goldbull22, NCZ, FA, Short, 27/09/18
https://hotcopper.com.au/threads/short-term-trading-week-starting-24-sept.4450085/?post_id=35892092
Petertkd, AUZ, TA, Long, 27/09/18
https://hotcopper.com.au/threads/short-term-trading-week-starting-24-sept.4450085/?post_id=35875937
starsky, PNV, TA, Long, 27/09/18
https://hotcopper.com.au/threads/short-term-trading-week-starting-24-sept.4450085/?post_id=35886493
bevter, NIU, FA, Long, 26/09/18
https://hotcopper.com.au/threads/short-term-trading-week-starting-24-sept.4450085/?post_id=35848487
Malaga, SL1, FA, Long, 26/09/18
https://hotcopper.com.au/threads/short-term-trading-week-starting-24-sept.4450085/?post_id=35862116
Petertkd, PNN, TA, Long, 26/09/18
https://hotcopper.com.au/threads/short-term-trading-week-starting-24-sept.4450085/?post_id=35861588
specgoldbug, NIU, TA, Long, 25/09/18
https://hotcopper.com.au/threads/short-term-trading-week-starting-24-sept.4450085/?post_id=35830286
Techmeister, MOB, FA, Long, 25/09/18
https://hotcopper.com.au/threads/short-term-trading-week-starting-24-sept.4450085/?post_id=35817983
Michaeljob, HZR, TA, Long, 24/09/18
https://hotcopper.com.au/threads/short-term-trading-week-starting-24-sept.4450085/?post_id=35787677
jimmityg, CTM, FA, Long, 21/09/18
https://hotcopper.com.au/threads/short-term-trading-week-starting-17-sept.4435109/?post_id=35744390
madbutcher, BLK, TA, Long, 21/09/18
https://hotcopper.com.au/threads/short-term-trading-week-starting-17-sept.4435109/?post_id=35757335
Michaeljob, SL1, TA, Long, 21/09/18
https://hotcopper.com.au/threads/short-term-trading-week-starting-17-sept.4435109/?post_id=35751899
vogliobene, ARE, FA, Long, 19/09/18
https://hotcopper.com.au/threads/short-term-trading-week-starting-17-sept.4435109/?post_id=35710571
bosco222, 88E, TA, Long, 18/09/18
https://hotcopper.com.au/threads/short-term-trading-week-starting-17-sept.4435109/?post_id=35672906
bosco222, AKM, FA, Long, 18/09/18
https://hotcopper.com.au/threads/short-term-trading-week-starting-17-sept.4435109/?post_id=35670971
bosco222, CVN, TA, Long, 18/09/18
https://hotcopper.com.au/threads/short-term-trading-week-starting-17-sept.4435109/?post_id=35670683
madbutcher, MOY, TA, Long, 17/09/18
https://hotcopper.com.au/threads/short-term-trading-week-starting-17-sept.4435109/?post_id=35645199
senderos, EUZ, TA, Long, 17/09/18
https://hotcopper.com.au/threads/short-term-trading-week-starting-17-sept.4435109/?post_id=35654528
Sharetrader78, EAR, FA, Long, 17/09/18
https://hotcopper.com.au/threads/short-term-trading-week-starting-17-sept.4435109/?post_id=35655815
Sharetrader78, RLE, FA, Long, 17/09/18
https://hotcopper.com.au/threads/short-term-trading-week-starting-17-sept.4435109/?post_id=35654330
Create, EMP, TA, Long, 15/09/18
Mansolo, AGY, TA, Short, 14/09/18
https://hotcopper.com.au/threads/short-term-trading-week-starting-10-sept.4419758/?post_id=35593211
gurnz1, EWC, TA, Long, 13/09/18
https://hotcopper.com.au/threads/short-term-trading-week-starting-10-sept.4419758/?post_id=35571893
croc49, MWR, TA, Long, 12/09/18
https://hotcopper.com.au/threads/short-term-trading-week-starting-10-sept.4419758/?post_id=35540468
Ibza, IPB, TA, Long, 12/09/18
https://hotcopper.com.au/threads/short-term-trading-week-starting-10-sept.4419758/?post_id=35562197
madbutcher, REH, TA, Short, 10/09/18
https://hotcopper.com.au/threads/short-term-trading-week-starting-10-sept.4419758/?post_id=35498187
ArthurDent, VMC, FA, Long, 06/09/18
https://hotcopper.com.au/threads/short-term-trading-week-starting-3-sept.4407344/?post_id=35440651
Banker, HLX, TA, Long, 06/09/18
https://hotcopper.com.au/threads/short-term-trading-week-starting-3-sept.4407344/?post_id=35455917
pmd3nka, RSG, TA, Short, 06/09/18
https://hotcopper.com.au/threads/short-term-trading-week-starting-3-sept.4407344/?post_id=35450767
vermkart, WKT, FA, Long, 06/09/18
https://hotcopper.com.au/threads/short-term-trading-week-starting-3-sept.4407344/?post_id=35456729
vogliobene, VEC, FA, Long, 06/09/18
https://hotcopper.com.au/threads/short-term-trading-week-starting-3-sept.4407344/?post_id=35440655
Mansolo, EXL, TA, Long, 05/09/18
https://hotcopper.com.au/threads/short-term-trading-week-starting-3-sept.4407344/?post_id=35436391
fedcba, S3R, FA, Long, 04/09/18
https://hotcopper.com.au/threads/short-term-trading-week-starting-3-sept.4407344/?post_id=35415956
vogliobene, PCL, FA, Long, 04/09/18
https://hotcopper.com.au/threads/short-term-trading-week-starting-3-sept.4407344/?post_id=35397203
vogliobene, VRC, FA, Long, 04/09/18
https://hotcopper.com.au/threads/short-term-trading-week-starting-3-sept.4407344/?post_id=35412266
Goldbull22, KDR, TA, Short, 03/09/18
https://hotcopper.com.au/threads/short-term-trading-week-starting-3-sept.4407344/?post_id=35384399
Techmeister, DSE, FA, Long, 03/09/18
https://hotcopper.com.au/threads/short-term-trading-week-starting-3-sept.4407344/?post_id=35379935
john435, BDG, FA, Long, 02/09/18
Resq22, AIS, FA, Long, 02/09/18
Resq22, ARE, FA, Long, 02/09/18
Resq22, ARE, TA, Long, 02/09/18
zero2a$mill, NES, FA, Long, 02/09/18
mouse, LNU, TA, Long, 01/09/18
Goldbull22, TNR, FA, Long, 30/08/18
https://hotcopper.com.au/threads/short-term-trading-week-starting-27-aug.4386764/?post_id=35307461
Ibza, ASN, TA, Long, 30/08/18
https://hotcopper.com.au/threads/short-term-trading-week-starting-27-aug.4386764/?post_id=35308373
pmd3nka, RSG, TA, Short, 29/08/18
https://hotcopper.com.au/threads/short-term-trading-week-starting-27-aug.4386764/?post_id=35258318
senderos, AXP, TA, Long, 29/08/18
https://hotcopper.com.au/threads/short-term-trading-week-starting-27-aug.4386764/?post_id=35278373
journeyman, TNG, FA, Long, 28/08/18
https://hotcopper.com.au/threads/short-term-trading-week-starting-27-aug.4386764/?post_id=35249738
bosco222, BOE, TA, Long, 27/08/18
bosco222, FGF, FA, Long, 27/08/18
pmd3nka, AMI, FA, Long, 27/08/18
https://hotcopper.com.au/threads/short-term-trading-week-starting-27-aug.4386764/?post_id=35202227
pmd3nka, CVN, TA, Short, 27/08/18
https://hotcopper.com.au/threads/short-term-trading-week-starting-27-aug.4386764/?post_id=35206664
Sharetrader78, IRC, FA, Long, 27/08/18
https://hotcopper.com.au/threads/short-term-trading-week-starting-27-aug.4386764/?post_id=35216720
vermkart, MNC, FA, Long, 27/08/18
https://hotcopper.com.au/threads/short-term-trading-week-starting-27-aug.4386764/?post_id=35219414
Mansolo, K2F, TA, Long, 26/08/18
ColonialCousin, JKA, FA, Long, 25/08/18
Goldbull22, APT, FA, Short, 25/08/18
Dazedandconfused, FGO, TA, Long, 23/08/18
https://hotcopper.com.au/threads/short-term-trading-week-starting-20-aug.4367696/?post_id=35136410
madbutcher, BOE, TA, Long, 23/08/18
https://hotcopper.com.au/threads/short-term-trading-week-starting-20-aug.4367696/?post_id=35119235
madbutcher, CTM, TA, Long, 23/08/18
https://hotcopper.com.au/threads/short-term-trading-week-starting-20-aug.4367696/?post_id=35141354
madbutcher, MRQ, TA, Short, 23/08/18
https://hotcopper.com.au/threads/short-term-trading-week-starting-20-aug.4367696/?post_id=35128460
Mansolo, CLV, TA, Long, 23/08/18
https://hotcopper.com.au/threads/short-term-trading-week-starting-20-aug.4367696/?post_id=35141153
ozzy9, SAS, TA, Long, 21/08/18
https://hotcopper.com.au/threads/short-term-trading-week-starting-20-aug.4367696/?post_id=35059511
vogliobene, WBE, FA, Long, 21/08/18
https://hotcopper.com.au/threads/short-term-trading-week-starting-20-aug.4367696/?post_id=35067599
pmd3nka, BOE, TA, Long, 20/08/18
https://hotcopper.com.au/threads/short-term-trading-week-starting-20-aug.4367696/?post_id=35039783
pmd3nka, SIG, TA, Long, 20/08/18
https://hotcopper.com.au/threads/short-term-trading-week-starting-20-aug.4367696/?post_id=35039378
valvesound, ASP, FA, Long, 20/08/18
https://hotcopper.com.au/threads/short-term-trading-week-starting-20-aug.4367696/?post_id=35034608
vogliobene, SIG, FA, Long, 20/08/18
https://hotcopper.com.au/threads/short-term-trading-week-starting-20-aug.4367696/?post_id=35038451
vogliobene, VPC, FA, Long, 20/08/18
https://hotcopper.com.au/threads/short-term-trading-week-starting-20-aug.4367696/?post_id=35034167
vogliobene, WEC, FA, Long, 20/08/18
https://hotcopper.com.au/threads/short-term-trading-week-starting-20-aug.4367696/?post_id=35039030
markeewan, STA, TA, Long, 19/08/18
gurnz1, CLQ, TA, Long, 18/08/18
peejayhercules, FNT, TA, Long, 18/08/18
BigBear001, AC8, FA, Long, 17/08/18
https://hotcopper.com.au/threads/short-term-trading-week-starting-13-aug.4353882/?post_id=34986287
Mansolo, KSL, TA, Long, 16/08/18
https://hotcopper.com.au/threads/short-term-trading-week-starting-13-aug.4353882/?post_id=34967124
CestLaVie, DTZ, FA, Long, 14/08/18
https://hotcopper.com.au/threads/short-term-trading-week-starting-13-aug.4353882/?post_id=34918749
vindin, FLC, FA, Long, 14/08/18
https://hotcopper.com.au/threads/short-term-trading-week-starting-13-aug.4353882/?post_id=34925358
vindin, FLC, TA, Long, 14/08/18
https://hotcopper.com.au/threads/short-term-trading-week-starting-13-aug.4353882/?post_id=34924143
senderos, CLT, FA, Long, 12/08/18
senderos, IVZ, TA, Long, 12/08/18
flippinpips, VPC, FA, Long, 11/08/18
kellbys, GBR, FA, Long, 11/08/18
vermkart, G1A, FA, Long, 10/08/18
https://hotcopper.com.au/threads/short-term-trading-week-starting-6th-aug.4338942/?post_id=34847115
Malaga, LOM, FA, Long, 08/08/18
https://hotcopper.com.au/threads/short-term-trading-week-starting-6th-aug.4338942/?post_id=34817490
Mansolo, AGY, TA, Short, 07/08/18
https://hotcopper.com.au/threads/short-term-trading-week-starting-6th-aug.4338942/?post_id=34774038
syzygy, CVN, FA, Long, 07/08/18
https://hotcopper.com.au/threads/short-term-trading-week-starting-6th-aug.4338942/?post_id=34781235
bosco222, AYR, FA, Long, 06/08/18
https://hotcopper.com.au/threads/short-term-trading-week-starting-6th-aug.4338942/?post_id=34734639
bosco222, IVZ, TA, Long, 06/08/18
https://hotcopper.com.au/threads/short-term-trading-week-starting-6th-aug.4338942/?post_id=34760205
bosco222, SPQ, TA, Long, 06/08/18
https://hotcopper.com.au/threads/short-term-trading-week-starting-6th-aug.4338942/?post_id=34760133
flippinpips, CLZ, FA, Long, 06/08/18
https://hotcopper.com.au/threads/short-term-trading-week-starting-6th-aug.4338942/?post_id=34744671
Bugsam, MYL, TA, Long, 05/08/18
https://hotcopper.com.au/threads/short-term-trading-weekend-lounge-3-5-aug.4337732/?post_id=34731102
markeewan, JKA, FA, Long, 05/08/18
https://hotcopper.com.au/threads/short-term-trading-weekend-lounge-3-5-aug.4337732/?post_id=34726671
markeewan, WZR, FA, Long, 05/08/18
https://hotcopper.com.au/threads/short-term-trading-weekend-lounge-3-5-aug.4337732/?post_id=34727340
radx, PEN, TA, Long, 05/08/18
https://hotcopper.com.au/threads/short-term-trading-weekend-lounge-3-5-aug.4337732/?post_id=34730157
Mansolo, PEN, TA, Long, 04/08/18
https://hotcopper.com.au/threads/short-term-trading-weekend-lounge-3-5-aug.4337732/?post_id=34724736
Beard_of_Zeus, EMP, FA, Long, 03/08/18
coefficient, ELO, TA, Long, 03/08/18
kellbys, S66, FA, Long, 03/08/18
https://hotcopper.com.au/threads/short-term-trading-weekend-lounge-3-5-aug.4337732/?post_id=34715722
Techmeister, DSE, FA, Long, 02/08/18
mr_delta, COI, TA, Long, 01/08/18