You're like the guy at the poker table who wants to criticise...

You're like the guy at the poker table who wants to criticise how everyone plays but doesn't actually want to be in a better game.

If you're here to debate the pros and cons are different trading philosophies, then it is axiomatic that you should engage in debate: under those circumstances integrity would oblige you to show us how to do it right if you think I'm doing it wrong...

If you're here to gauge sentiment, and you think my methodology is wrong, you should shut-up and let others do it wrong and profit in the longer run.

There are only two reasons to try to suggest a stranger is wrong without correcting their methodology: 1. ego - if one wants to seem important and superior to others; or 2. if one fears that it would show others how to do it right which will make it harder for one to profit.

What other possible reason is there for you to pick a fight along the lines of "this guy is wrong, but I'm not going show anyone the right way"?

And yes: I agree this Elliot Waves thing is asinine.