What I meant before was even on his best pick the timing wasn't ideal. Another one AYN - timed it while silver was at it's peak, due diligence should have told him that the company was way overvalued at the time.
And finally, good old SYR, when he tipped it he mentioned how it had already rallied and was a risky proposition, so only invest half what you would usually. Then it actually paid off, and he gloats for weeks about his legend pick.