Eh ? How am I being defensive ? Gasman expressed his view ... I...

Eh ? How am I being defensive ? Gasman expressed his view ... I expressed mine ... no problems ... then you had to get hysterical and personal.

Why don't YOU do the quality, objective, unbiased, thorough, analytical research you keep banging on about, instead of just presenting an incomplete list of topic headings.

While you are doing it, don't forget the share market is people putting their money where their mouths are. Looking at todays share price for SGL, the market is saying the bid is fair.