I am posting after having held it before and having continued to follow the company.
As for Sundance, I'm not a bitter holder but if i had a half a billion and had to invest it in an IO mining project, SDL has what appears to be a much higher grade resource and i would put the $ with them over this any day.
.
I also held Hunnu Coal in the distant past and believe that gains i made there were very lucky timing. The acquirer would probably be pretty sour about that transaction right now.
I went into Haranga at a similar time when there was excessive hype around management.
Since then, this and other Garrison Capital backed companies have done pretty terribly by my reckoning.
Ones that i drew associations with some time ago include AVB (unfulfilled expectations), LIN (looking rubbish), WOF (poor performance), CCZ (almost gone), CRJ (gone).
The figures I used before were derived from the company presentation on 18/02/2014 (page 23) since which time I don't think that the company has done much to justify their salaries.
That presentation has a timeline which says they should be building the mine now and in production by 2016. Go figure!
I constructed a DCF using their inputs of a 12.5% discount rate, US131.5/t concentrate price, 16 year mine life, 3mtpa production rate, cash costs of $64 and the $562 million capex that they forecast to bring about their NPV.
Then I made my own adjustments to those figures given some changes to risk assumptions and cash costs,
When using cash costs of $70 (rather than their 64) and prices of $114, that is when my DCF calc came out as an NPV of zero.
My DCF calc is probably not worth the paper it is written on but i don't think theirs is either and that is probably why it isn't in any presentations I have seen lately.
Anyway, given current iron ore prices and the outlook, the inputs in their model from early 2014 are pretty unrealistic.
Sure, the Chinese might buy this but i don't think they will make a dime doing it.
Seriously happy to be proven wrong but without a takeover, I don't think that this is going anywhere .
All IMO DYOR
New Feature Announcement!
We’re excited to introduce the DealRoom portal, now live on site, providing users with exciting access to private equity opportunities for both pre-IPO and publicly listed companies.
See full details by selecting the new menu item named 'DealRoom' on our main menu bar or click below.
Stay ahead of the market, with HotCopper.