I don't think its a couple of negative posters clutching at...

I don't think its a couple of negative posters clutching at straws. They are legitimate concerns, SW1 has diversified now because their over-exposure in the mining sector has hit them significantly in the past, and it was because mines were closing all over WA. I think now they are diversified enough to absorb any downturn in the mining or other industries. There is quality discussion to be had about this, and i think the majority would agree the risk of material impact is minimal, but to put it down to a few posters clutching at straws is missing the point.