Hopefully it will be so that he can show them HOW to make money...

Hopefully it will be so that he can show them HOW to make money for their shareholders...us !
It doesnt and hasnt been apparent for about the last 3 years that they know how to do it themselves !
And, what is best ? Does that mean that they will achieve average returns if the market falls out of bed ?

Are you saying that they will ONLY make money in a falling market ? Cause they arent making any in a rising one !
How come WLE can outperform the market in their first year having only large cap stocks and ALF can even make a fraction of that averaged over 3 years.

Dont hold a flag for a stock despite evidence to the contrary. I noted that there were passionate shareholders of RFG who defended the company irrespective of the evidence pointed out to them. I recall people saying that they were going to keep buying all the way down to $2.00 and that stock is something like a quarter of that.

Please dont think that I am picking on you for your holding because its your money and you can choose to invest it as you choose. I just happen to have an opposing view based on what has occurred over the last 3 years.
Yes ! Geoff may have bought into ALF, but as you point out, we dont know why ! Only Geoff knows why and I predict that IF Geoff doesnt take a proactive role in changing the thought or investment process or the strategy that ALF employs, then we are going to be pretty much where we are now.
I hope Im wrong and happy to bet a pie and a coke on the outcome. DYOR.