Since I hold both I don't see an issue mentioning LYC here and...

Since I hold both I don't see an issue mentioning LYC here and yes, for change it is looking good but the reason it looks good is because the Chinese have made them look good by clamping down on illegal mines in their backyard . Give the Chinese a year or two to replace the illegal mines with new ones in Africa and neodymium prices will be going down again making Lynas unprofitable once again. Nice trading it short term but with ARU and PEK soon giving LYC a run for their money I wouldn't put too much of my super money on it.

As for the other bit on downramping if you'd look back over the number of negative posts you 2 have been making on NTU over the past few years despite not holding the stock you'd be accusing yourselves of downramping. Seriously, did you buy at 30c and sold at 6c only to see it double in price that made you bitter about NTU or do you just enjoy trolling here?